Messaging and profile culture

Emoticon history: from the 1982 smiley to chat graphics

Published

The typed smiley :-) appears in Scott Fahlman’s Carnegie Mellon post on 19 September 1982. He proposed it as a mark for jokes in text discussions. Chat programs later turned typed faces into small pictures, including moving emoticons in MSN Messenger 6.

On this page

In his own account, Fahlman describes the practical problem: readers sometimes took a joke seriously, and the resulting replies overwhelmed the discussion. Typed marks could hint that a line was a joke, even on a text-only screen.

Scott Fahlman smiles outdoors while holding a white sheet with a large sideways smiley made from punctuation.
A later portrait of Scott Fahlman, reproduced with PLDB’s 2022 interview. His text-smiley proposal dates to September 1982. Image: Scott Fahlman portrait, via PLDB. Source.

1982: give the reader a tone cue

The face fitted beside a sentence and used little space. Its meaning depended on the words around it.

Try this original sentence in three forms:

The words stay the same. The added mark suggests plain thanks, a friendly reply or a shared joke. Who wrote it and what came before still affect its meaning.

Fahlman originally proposed :-( for serious messages, while :-) marked jokes. He later wrote that the frown came to mean unhappiness. Its meaning had changed since the 1982 proposal.

1995: the convention enters netiquette

The 1995 Netiquette Guidelines, published as RFC 1855, include smileys as a way to show tone online.

A friend may understand your joke from one playful mark. A stranger may need clearer words as well. Ask whether the reader has enough clues to understand you.

For a practical exercise, write a short invitation in plain text. Add one face, then remove it and revise the words until they carry a similar tone.

2003: chat programs add moving pictures

Microsoft’s Messenger 6 announcement describes a wider choice of pictures, including animated faces and a birthday cake with flickering candles. Users could also customize their display pictures, backgrounds and emoticons.

An MSN Messenger 6 conversation window shows two display pictures, a lavender background and an open grid of colorful emoticons.
MSN Messenger 6.0.0250 in Zheng Haishan’s May 2003 review. Image: Zheng Haishan / Microsoft. Source.

You choose a picture and the program draws or moves it. A blink or changing face adds timing to a line that would otherwise stay still.

A typed face uses keyboard marks. A drawn face depends on the program’s picture, its size and the space around it. Two programs may show the same feeling with different pictures.

Typed faces and graphical emoticons

Form What carries the expression Example
Typed emoticon Visible keyboard characters :-)
Graphical emoticon The chat program’s picture A smiling face selected from its panel
Animated emoticon The moving pictures and their timing Messenger 6’s blinking or crying faces

The same typed characters can remain text in one application and turn into an image in another. A screenshot of the surrounding message shows what the reader actually saw.

Preserve the message and its setting

When studying a chat image, keep the program’s name, version, date and the full message around it.

Fahlman describes a search through old backup tapes that found the original discussion in 2002. The full conversation showed a group trying to find a way to mark jokes in writing.

Read the symbols in their setting

Use the old internet slang reference to decode common faces and abbreviations. MSN Messenger’s history shows how chat programs used these pictures; the guide to AIM away messages shows another way a short piece of text carried a personal voice.